Jackson v. Queens Borough Public Library
In November 2019, Disability Rights Advocates (DRA) filed a class action lawsuit on behalf of Plaintiffs Tanya Jackson and Center for Independence of the Disabled New York (CIDNY) against Queens Borough Public Library, The Board of Trustees of the Queens Borough Public Library, and the City of New York, challenging the inaccessibility of Hunters Point Library.
Under longstanding disability rights laws, newly constructed buildings must be made fully accessible to people with disabilities. Yet Hunters Point Library, which was an entirely new $41.5 million building constructed after years of in-depth planning, shockingly excluded persons with mobility disabilities from full and equal access to its services through reliance on stairs and other inaccessible features.
DRA’s goal was to rectify the exclusion of people with disabilities by requiring Defendants to develop and implement a remedial plan to provide equal access to Hunters Point Library. The suit alleged violations of the federal and local civil rights laws designed to eliminate disability-based discrimination.
In early 2025, DRA reached a settlement agreement providing for the remediation of accessibility barriers in Hunters Point Library. A federal court preliminarily approved the settlement agreement in June 2025 and then approved the settlement agreement in October 2025.
The settlement will result in significant changes to ensure visitors with mobility disabilities are able to visit, benefit from, and enjoy the library to the same extent as non-disabled visitors. Among other fixes, the library will remedy inaccessible multi-level seating in the children’s area and rooftop terrace and provide stair-free access to two previously inaccessible tiered sections of the library. The library will also remediate over a hundred other smaller accessibility barriers, including in the bathrooms and study areas.
Case Files
Press Releases
Media Coverage
- October 29, 2025: Legal Reader
Class Settlement Approved Ensuring Access for People with Disabilities to Queens Public Library Branch - October 24, 2025: World-Architects
Accessibility Issues at Steven Holl’s Hunters Point Library Resolved - October 23, 2025: Queens Chronicle
Judge OKs Work to Fix Library Debacle - October 20, 2025: Crain’s New York Business
Queens Library Gets $4.6M in Accessibility Fixes as Lawsuit against Architect Continues - October 16, 2025: Gothamist
Queens Library Agrees to Major Accessibility Upgrades after Disability Rights Lawsuit - October 14, 2025: Architect’s Newspaper
Disability Advocates Win Lawsuit against City of New York over Hunters Point Library, Designed by Steven Holl Architects - August 1, 2023: The Nation
The Future of Design Is Designing for Disability - July 24, 2023: Archinect
The Hunters Point Library Case Highlights the ADA’s Failures to Prevent Inequality by Design - July 19, 2023: Curbed
It’s Time to Retire the Grand Staircase - July 12, 2023: Next City
Accessibility Lawsuits Are Bringing Slow but Steady Wins for Disabled City Residents - June 24, 2023: Los Angeles Times
How Did a New York Public Library by Steven Holl Architects Get Accessibility So Wrong? - June 7, 2023: NY Times
New York City Sues Queens Library Architects Over Lack of Accessibility - May 25, 2023: Queens Chronicle
Editorial – Hunters Pt. Library a Big Mistake - May 24, 2023: Surface Magazine
Steven Holl Architects May Face Charges Over Hunters Point Library’s Accessibility - May 24, 2023: World Architects
Steven Holl Sued Over ‘Inaccessible’ Library Design - May 23, 2023: Business of Home
News Digest - May 22, 2023: Architects Newspaper
Steven Holl Architects Could Be on the Hook for $10 Million Over Hunters Point Library’s Inaccessibility - May 22, 2023: Patch
Hunters Point Library Designer Sued by the City Amid ADA Violations - May 21, 2023: NY Daily News
Hunters Point Library Architects Get Sued for Designing a Building Inaccessible to People With Disabilities - May 20, 2023: NY Post
NYC Sues Designer of $41M Hunters Point Library Over Handicapped ‘Inaccessibility’ - May 19, 2023: 6SqFt
NYC Sues Architecture Firm Behind New Long Island City Library Over Accessibility Issues - May 19, 2023: Archinect
New York City Sues Steven Holl Architects Over Inaccessible Hunters Point Library Design - May 19, 2023: Queens Chronicle
City Sues Hunters Point Library Architects - May 18, 2023: Crain’s NY
City Sues Architects Who Designed Inaccessible Hunters Point Library - February 10, 2023: Dezeen
Ten Buildings That Became Embroiled in Legal Battles - December 4, 2019: Spectrum News NY1
Queens Library’s LIC Jewel at Center of Class Action Lawsuit